927d9adb changed the way CATALOG_VERSION_NO is used to identify PostgreSQL versions since PG_CONTROL_VERSION is generally bumped with each release. The goal was to make the beta/rc period less painful because any CATALOG_VERSION_NO bump renders pgBackRest inoperative.
This worked, but in fact we'd rather be stricter about which CATALOG_VERSION_NO we accept when identifying a version of PostgreSQL. It is not just about identifying a major version, but making sure the build contains all the functions and catalogs we expect to make pgBackRest work correctly. It is better to reject early dev/beta/rc builds that may not work.
Since 927d9adb was relatively recent the chance that this stricter checking will cause a problem seems minimal, so revert to checking CATALOG_VERSION_NO for every PostgreSQL version.
Leave in place the code that pulls CATALOG_VERSION_NO from pg_control rather than the internal constant since the plan is still to allow catalog versions to "float" during the PostgreSQL beta/rc phase, which will be the subject of a future commit.
If an ok file (which indicates the WAL segment was not found) is present on the first iteration of the loop then remove it and spawn the async process to retry. This action also resets the queue.
Also error if no response is received from the async process rather than returning not found. PostgreSQL will respond the same either way, but this allows us to determine when something is going wrong with the async process.
Update archiveAsyncStatus() to allow warnings to be suppressed. It is better to retry if no WAL segment was found before warning because the warning might be stale.
Convert most of the remaining options that benefit from being StringIds. Since all the command modules can include config.h directly it makes sense to auto-generate these values instead of manually creating an enum for each one.
For the time being StringIds are not being auto-generated because the StringId code does not exist in Perl. However, the *_Z zero-terminated constants for each allowed option value are now auto-generated.
Allows removal of backupType()/backupTypeStr() and improves debug logging of the enum.
Move BackupType enum and string constants to info/infoBackup.h so they are available to more modules. Also convert InfoBackup to use BackupType instead of a String.
It is no longer possible to pull news source from the PostgreSQL website so add a sample in the doc directory. Update the release instructions to reflect this change.
Also note that it is no longer necessary to post separately to pgsql-announce.
Using StringId for the client/session type removes String constants and some awkward referencing/dereferencing needed to use a String constant in the interface.
Converting IoSessionRole to StringId removes a conditional in ioSessionToLog() and improves debug logging by outputting client/server instead of 0/1.
Centralize the formatting of the configuration value for display to the user or passing on a command line.
For the new functions, if the value was set by the user via the command line, config, etc., then that exact value will be displayed. This makes it easier for the user to recognize the value and saves having to format it into something reasonable, especially for time and size option types.
Note that cfgOptTypeHash and cfgOptTypeList option types are not supported by these functions, but they are generally not displayed to the user as a whole.
This also fixes a bug in config/load.c where time values where not being formatted correctly in an error message.
Use StringIds for the storage types (e.g. STORAGE_S3_TYPE) and configuration settings, e.g. cfgOptS3KeyType.
Also add new config functions and harness config functions to support StringIds.
There is no need to write the file atomically (e.g. via a temp file on Posix) because checksums are tested on resume after a failed backup. The path does not need be synced for each file because all paths are synced at the end of the backup.
This functionality was not lost during the migration -- it never existed in the Perl code, though these settings are used in restore. See 59f1353 where backupFile() was migrated to C.
Fix the segfault when getting help for an internal option is requested by adding help for all internal options that are valid for a default command role.
Also print warnings about internal options in code rather than putting in each command/option description.
The remotes are no longer needed in the main process after the manifest is loaded. If the restore is long enough the connection will timeout and WARN at the end of the restore. This is harmless for the restore but distracting for the user.
To prevent this, free the remotes once they are no longer needed.
Getting help for a valid option that was invalid for the command would segfault.
Add a check to ensure the option is valid for the command's default role.
It is often useful to represent identifiers as strings when they cannot easily be represented as an enum/integer, e.g. because they are distributed among a number of unrelated modules or need to be passed to remote processes. Strings are also more helpful in debugging since they can be recognized without cross-referencing the source. However, strings are awkward to work with in C since they cannot be directly used in switch statements leading to less efficient if-else structures.
A StringId encodes a short string into an integer so it can be used in switch statements but may also be readily converted back into a string for debugging purposes. StringIds may also be suitable for matching user input providing the strings are short enough.
This patch includes a sample of StringId usage by converting protocol commands to StringIds. There are many other possible use cases. To list a few:
* All "types" in storage, filters. IO , etc. These types are primarily for identification and debugging so they fit well with this model.
* MemContext names would work well as StringIds since these are entirely for debugging.
* Option values could be represented as StringIds which would mean we could remove the functions that convert strings to enums, e.g. CipherType.
* There are a number of places where enums need to be converted back to strings for logging/debugging purposes. An example is protocolParallelJobToConstZ. If ProtocolParallelJobState were defined as:
typedef enum
{
protocolParallelJobStatePending = STRID5("pend", ...),
protocolParallelJobStateRunning = STRID5("run", ...),
protocolParallelJobStateDone = STRID5("done", ...),
} ProtocolParallelJobState;
then protocolParallelJobToConstZ() could be replaced with strIdToZ(). This also applies to many enums that we don't covert to strings for logging, such as CipherMode.
As an example of usage, convert all protocol commands from strings to StringIds.
Restore excluding the specified databases. Databases excluded will be restored as sparse, zeroed files to save space but still allow PostgreSQL to perform recovery. After recovery, those databases will not be accessible but can be removed with the drop database command. The --db-exclude option can be passed multiple times to specify more than one database to exclude.
When used in combination with the --db-include option, --db-exclude will only apply to standard system databases (template0, template1, and postgres).
In combination with the thisPub() function, this macro simplifies accessing the public part of a private object struct.
thisPub() asserts this != NULL so the caller does not need to do it.
Introduce a standard pattern for exposing public struct members (as documented in CODING.md) and use it to inline lstSize() which should improve the performance of iterating large lists.
Since many functions in these modules are just thin wrappers of other functions, inline where appropriate.
Remove strLstExistsZ() and strLstInsertZ() since they were only used in tests, where the String version of the function is sufficient.
Move strLstNewSplitSizeZ() to command/help/help.c and remove strLstNewSplitSize(). This function has only ever been used by help and does not seem widely applicable.
Bug Fixes:
* Fix option warnings breaking async archive-get/archive-push. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang. Reported by Lev Kokotov.)
* Fix memory leak in backup during archive copy. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang. Reported by Christian ROUX, Efremov Egor.)
* Fix stack overflow in cipher passphrase generation. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang. Reported by bsiara.)
* Fix repo-ls / on S3 repositories. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang. Reported by Lesovsky Alexey.)
Features:
* Multiple repository support. (Contributed by Cynthia Shang, David Steele. Reviewed by Stefan Fercot, Stephen Frost.)
* GCS support for repository storage. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang.)
* Add archive-header-check option. (Reviewed by Stephen Frost, Cynthia Shang. Suggested by Hans-Jürgen Schönig.)
Improvements:
* Include recreated system databases during selective restore. (Contributed by Stefan Fercot. Reviewed by Cynthia Shang.)
* Exclude content-length from S3 signed headers. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang. Suggested by Brian P Bockelman.)
* Consolidate less commonly used repository storage options. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang.)
* Allow custom config-path default with ./configure --with-configdir. (Contributed by Michael Schout. Reviewed by David Steele.)
* Log archive copy during backup. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang, Stefan Fercot.)
Documentation Improvements:
* Update reference to include links to user guide examples. (Contributed by Cynthia Shang. Reviewed by David Steele.)
* Update selective restore documentation with caveats. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang, Stefan Fercot.)
* Add compress-type clarification to archive-copy documentation. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang, Stefan Fercot.)
* Add compress-level defaults per compress-type value. (Contributed by Cynthia Shang. Reviewed by David Steele.)
* Add note about required NFS settings being the same as PostgreSQL. (Contributed by Cynthia Shang. Reviewed by David Steele.)
The command-example and command-example-list elements were removed from the documentation rendering some time ago so these tags were dead code. The tags, however, contained some examples and information that were pertinent to the command, so where possible, the information was included in the description of the command and/or the user-guide and links to the relevant user guide sections were added.
Note that some commands could not be updated with user guide references since doing so would cause a cyclical reference in the user guide. These commands have an internal comment to indicate this.
In addition, some clarifications were added (e.g. expire --set option) where information was lacking.
Enabled by default, this option checks the WAL header against the PostgreSQL version and system identifier to ensure that the WAL is being copied to the correct stanza. This is in addition to checking pg_control against the stanza and verifying that WAL is being copied from the same PostgreSQL data directory where pg_control is located.
Therefore, disabling this check is fairly safe but should only be done when required, e.g. if the WAL is encrypted.
3b8f0ef missed some cases that could cause archive-push to fail:
* Checking archive info.
* Checking to see if a WAL segment already exists.
These cases are now handled so archive-push can succeed on any valid repos.
This improvement reduces the number of errors thrown; these errors will now be reported as a status for the stanza or repo as appropriate. Invalid option configurations are still thrown but all other errors are caught, formatted and reported. This was necessary for multiple repositories so that the command can complete gathering information from each repository and report the results rather than immediately aborting when an error occurs.
Two new error codes were introduced:
6 = requested backup not found
99 = other, which is used to indicate an error has occurred that requires more details to be provided
A new stanza name of "[invalid]" was created for instances where a stanza was not specified and no stanza can be found.
If there is only one repository configured the error will move up to the stanza level with the standard error formatting of 'error (message)' where the message will be "other" and the details of the error will be listed on the next line(s):
stanza: stanza1
status: error (other)
[CryptoError] unable to load info file '/var/lib/pgbackrest/repo/backup/stanza1/backup.info' or '/var/lib/pgbackrest/repo/backup/stanza1/backup.info.copy':
CryptoError: cipher header invalid
HINT: is or was the repo encrypted?
FileMissingError: unable to open missing file '/var/lib/pgbackrest/repo/backup/stanza1/backup.info.copy' for read
HINT: backup.info cannot be opened and is required to perform a backup.
HINT: has a stanza-create been performed?
HINT: use option --stanza if encryption settings are different for the stanza than the global
cipher: aes-256-cbc
If a backup set is requested but is not found on any repo, a stanza-level status error of 'requested backup not found' is reported when there are no other errors:
pgbackrest info --stanza=demo --set=bogus
stanza: demo
status: error (requested backup not found)
cipher: mixed
repo1: aes-256-cbc
repo2: none
If there are multiple repositories configured and a single repo is in error but the other repos are ok or have a different error:
pgbackrest info --stanza=demo --set=20210322-171211F
stanza: demo
status: mixed
repo1: error
[CryptoError] unable to load info file '/var/lib/pgbackrest/repo/backup/stanza1/backup.info' or '/var/lib/pgbackrest/repo/backup/stanza1/backup.info.copy':
CryptoError: cipher header invalid
HINT: is or was the repo encrypted?
FileMissingError: unable to open missing file '/var/lib/pgbackrest/repo/backup/stanza1/backup.info.copy' for read
HINT: backup.info cannot be opened and is required to perform a backup.
HINT: has a stanza-create been performed?
HINT: use option --stanza if encryption settings are different for the stanza than the global
repo2: ok
cipher: mixed
repo1: aes-256-cbc
repo2: none
db (current)
wal archive min/max (12): 000000010000000000000001/000000010000000000000003
full backup: 20210322-171211F
timestamp start/stop: 2021-03-22 17:12:11 / 2021-03-22 17:12:28
wal start/stop: 000000010000000000000002 / 000000010000000000000002
database size: 23.4MB, database backup size: 23.4MB
repo2: backup set size: 2.8MB, backup size: 2.8MB
database list: postgres (13359)
Json output will include the repository information and any error information. If no stanzas are found, then [invalid] will be set as the name:
[
{
"archive":[],
"backup":[],
"cipher":"none",
"db":[],
"name":"[invalid]",
"repo":[
{
"cipher":"none",
"key":1,
"status":{
"code":99,
"message":"[PathOpenError] unable to list file info for path '/var/lib/pgbackrest/repo2/backup': [13] Permission denied"
}
}
],
"status":{
"code":99,
"lock":{"backup":{"held":false}},
"message":"other"
}
}
]
The content-length header was being signed since it was the only header that didn't need to be and it seemed simpler just to sign it as well. Also, the S3 documentation encourages signing as many headers as possible to avoid tampering.
However, some proxies munge this header causing authentication failure, so skip signing content-length.
Make protocol handlers have one function per command. This allows the logic of finding the handler to be in ProtocolServer, isolates each command to a function, and removes the need to test the "not found" condition for each handler.
S3 returns 200 for HEAD / which indicates it is a file but does not return the expected headers which causes an error.
Rather than fix this for S3, just automatically return / as not existing for any storage that does not support paths.
Also add some defensive checks to prevent this from generating a segfault if it happens again.
Some standard system databases (e.g. postgres) may be recreated by the user and have an OID that makes them look like user databases.
Identify the standard three system databases (template0, template1, postgres) and restore them non-zeroed no matter what OID they have.
Recovery may error unless --type=immediate is specified. This is because after consistency is reached PostgreSQL will flag zeroed pages as errors even for a full-page write.
For PostgreSQL ≥ 13 the ignore_invalid_pages setting may be used to ignore invalid pages. In this case it is important to check the logs after recovery to ensure that no invalid pages were reported in the selected databases.
It is best if the archive-push and backup commands have the same compress-type (e.g. lz4) when using archive-copy. Otherwise, the WAL segments will need to be recompressed with the compress-type used by the backup, which can be fairly expensive depending on how much WAL was generated during the backup.
There was already leakage here but when the compression transcoding was added it became a deluge.
There is some argument to be made that the filters should clean themselves up better but a temp mem context makes sense here anyway so do that.
The stanza-create, stanza-upgrade and stanza-delete were required to be run on the repository host. When there was only one repository allowed this was not a problem.
However, with the introduction of multiple repository support, this becomes more of a burden to the user, therefore the stanza-create, stanza-upgrade and stanza-delete commands have been improved to allow for them to be run remotely.
Moving to YAML allows the configuration data to be read by C programs.
Also go back to using YAML::XS since it is the only implementation that has proper boolean support.
Up to four repositories may be configured. A potential benefit is the ability to have a local repository for fast restores and a remote repository for redundancy.
Some commands, e.g. stanza-create/stanza-update, will automatically work with all configured repositories while others, e.g. stanza-delete, will require a repository to be specified using the repo option. See the command reference for details on which commands require the repository to be specified.
Note that the repo option is not required when only repo1 is configured in order to maintain backward compatibility. However, the repo option is required when a single repo is configured as, e.g. repo2. This is to prevent command breakage if a new repository is added later.
The archive-push command will always push WAL to the archive in all configured repositories but backups will need to be scheduled individually for each repository. In many cases this is desirable since backup types and retention will vary by repository. Likewise, restores must specify a repository. It is generally better to specify a repository for restores that has low latency/cost even if that means more recovery time. Only restore testing can determine which repository will be most efficient.
For single repository configurations there should be no change in behavior.
The HTML command reference was showing some options that were not valid because it did not properly understand the new role validity system. Also, the custom section for the new repo option was not being honored.
This is a bit messy because it leads to some duplicated code in help.c but there doesn't seem to be any way to fix that with the Perl data structures as they are.
This code is being migrated to C so it doesn't seem worth messing with it too much with the risk of breaking other things.
Some commands (repo-*, verify) still required the --repo option but it makes sense to give them the same treatment as backup and simply use the first repo when one is not specified.
This leaves stanza-delete as the only remaining command that requires --repo. This is by design to enhance safe usage.
The following options are renamed as specified:
repo1-azure-ca-file -> repo1-storage-ca-file
repo1-azure-ca-path -> repo1-storage-ca-path
repo1-azure-host -> repo1-storage-host
repo1-azure-port -> repo1-storage-port
repo1-azure-verify-tls -> repo1-storage-verify-tls
repo1-s3-ca-file -> repo1-storage-ca-file
repo1-s3-ca-path -> repo1-storage-ca-path
repo1-s3-host -> repo1-storage-host
repo1-s3-port -> repo1-storage-port
repo1-s3-verify-tls -> repo1-storage-verify-tls
The old option names (e.g. repo1-s3-port) will continue to work for repo1, but repo2, etc. will require the new names.
