There is no need to have parallelism enabled in a backup control session. In particular, 9.6 marks pg_stop_backup() as parallel-safe but an error will be thrown if pg_stop_backup() is run in a worker.
When uploading large files the upload is split into multiple parts which are assembled at the end to create the final file. Previously we waited until each part was acknowledged before starting on the processing (i.e. compression, etc.) of the next part.
Now, the request for each part is sent while processing continues and the response is read just before sending the request for the next part. This asynchronous method allows us to continue processing while the S3 server formulates a response.
Testing from outside AWS in a high-bandwidth, low-latency environment showed a 35% improvement in the upload time of 1GB files. The time spent waiting for multipart notifications was reduced by ~300% (this measurement included the final part which is not uploaded asynchronously).
There are still some possible improvements: 1) the creation of the multipart id could be made asynchronous when it looks like the upload will need to be multipart (this may incur cost if the upload turns out not to be multipart). 2) allow more than one async request (this will use more memory).
A fair amount of refactoring was required to make the HTTP responses asynchronous. This may seem like overkill but having well-defined request, response, and session objects will also be advantageous for the upcoming HTTP server functionality.
Another advantage is that the lifecycle of an HttpSession is better defined. We only want to reuse sessions that complete the request/response cycle successfully, otherwise we consider the session to be in a bad state and would prefer to start clean with a new one. Previously, this required complex notifications to mark a session as "successfully done". Now, ownership of the session is passed to the request and then the response and only returned to the client after a successful response. If an error occurs anywhere along the way the session will be automatically closed by the object destructor when the request/response object is freed (depending on which one currently owns the session).
strCat() did not follow our convention of appending Z to functions that accept zero-terminated strings rather than String objects.
Add strCatZ() to accept zero-terminated strings and update strCat() to accept String objects.
Use LF_STR where appropriate but don't use other String constants because they do not improve readability.
Test matrices were previously simplified for the mock/* tests (e.g. d4410611, d489eb87) but not for real/all since the rules for which tests would run with which options was extremely complex. This only got more complex when new compression formats were added.
Because the loop-generated matrix was so large, mosts tests were skipped for most option combinations following arcane logic which was nearly impossible to decipher even when reading the code, and completely impossible from the test.pl interface. As a consequence, important tests got excluded. For example, backup from standby was excluded for most versions of PostgreSQL because it was only run once per distro, against the latest version to be included in that distro.
Simplify the tests by having a single run per PostgreSQL version and vary test parameters according to the capabilities of each version and the underlying distro. So, ZST testing is based on whether the distro supports ZST. Every test is run for each set of parameters based on the capabilities of the PostgreSQL version, e.g. backup from standby is not attempted on versions that don't support it.
Note that since more tests are running the overall time to run the mock/all tests has increased by about 20-25%. Some time may be saved my removing tests that are adequately covered by unit tests but that should the subject of another commit. Another option would be to limit some non version-specific tests to a single, well defined version of PostgreSQL, .e.g the version that is run by expect tests, currently 9.6.
The motivation for this refactor is that new storage drivers are coming and the loop-generated test matrix simply was not up to the task of adding them.
The following is an example of the new test log (note longer runtime of each test):
module=real, test=all, run=1, pg-version=10 (106.91s)
module=real, test=all, run=1, pg-version=9.5 (151.09s)
module=real, test=all, run=1, pg-version=9.2 (123.11s)
module=real, test=all, run=1, pg-version=9.1 (129s)
vs. the old test log (sub-second tests were skipped entirely):
module=real, test=all, run=2, pg-version=10 (0.31s)
module=real, test=all, run=3, pg-version=10 (0.26s)
module=real, test=all, run=4, pg-version=10 (60.39s)
module=real, test=all, run=1, pg-version=10 (69.12s)
module=real, test=all, run=6, pg-version=10 (34s)
module=real, test=all, run=5, pg-version=10 (42.75s)
module=real, test=all, run=2, pg-version=9.5 (0.21s)
module=real, test=all, run=3, pg-version=9.5 (0.21s)
module=real, test=all, run=4, pg-version=9.5 (0.21s)
module=real, test=all, run=5, pg-version=9.5 (0.26s)
module=real, test=all, run=6, pg-version=9.5 (0.21s)
module=real, test=all, run=1, pg-version=9.2 (72.78s)
module=real, test=all, run=2, pg-version=9.2 (0.26s)
module=real, test=all, run=3, pg-version=9.2 (0.31s)
module=real, test=all, run=4, pg-version=9.2 (0.21s)
module=real, test=all, run=5, pg-version=9.2 (0.21s)
module=real, test=all, run=6, pg-version=9.2 (0.21s)
module=real, test=all, run=1, pg-version=9.5 (88.41s)
module=real, test=all, run=2, pg-version=9.1 (0.21s)
module=real, test=all, run=3, pg-version=9.1 (0.26s)
module=real, test=all, run=4, pg-version=9.1 (0.21s)
module=real, test=all, run=5, pg-version=9.1 (0.31s)
module=real, test=all, run=6, pg-version=9.1 (0.26s)
module=real, test=all, run=1, pg-version=9.1 (72.4s)
The unsupported version error is showing up on older versions of PostgreSQL (e.g. 9.1, 9.2) on RHEL6 when setting up a standby with streaming replication. The error occurs when a client does not properly send a version number and it's not clear why it is happening here, but it does not appear to have anything to do with pgBackRest and only affects RHEL6, i.e. 9.1 and 9.2 do not show this error on other distros.
For now ignore the error since RHEL6 is nearly EOL.
HTTP is an acronym so it should be capitalized. Coding conventions dictate otherwise for function and type names but that should not have been propagated to comments and messages.
strPtr() is called more than any other function and during profiling (with or without optimization) it can end up using a disproportionate amount of the total runtime. Even though it is fast, the profiler has a minimum resolution for each function call so strPtr() will often end up towards the top of the list even though the real runtime is quite small.
Instead, inline strPtr() and indicate to gcc that it should be inlined even for non-optimized builds, since that's how profiles are usually generated.
To make strPtr() smaller require "this" to be non-NULL and add another function, strPtrNull(), to deal with the few cases where we need NULL handling.
As a bonus this makes the executable about 1% smaller even when compared to a prior optimized build which would inline some percentage of strPtr() calls.
There is no sense in generating detailed coverage reports in CI environments where they will never be seen. It takes time and format differences in some older versions can cause problems in the report generation code.
Note that missing coverage will still be reported on stdout and the test will fail.
These were missed in d41eea68 when the functionality of TEST_RESULT_STR() was changed. Using TEST_RESULT_STR() instead of TEST_RESULT_PTR() is more type-safe and clearer.
Add a comment to make it clear that TEST_RESULT_PTR() should be used only when a better alternative is not available.
This aligns better with general PostgreSQL usage and our own documentation (updated in 4bcef702).
Usage in the backup.manifest tests has not been updated since it might break the file format.
Expressions only worked at the first level of recursion because the expression was also being applied to paths so the path had to match the filter in order to recurse.
This is not considered a bug since it does not affect any existing code paths, but it is required for the general-purpose repo-ls command.
A truncated HTTP response status could lead to an an unfriendly error message, which would be retried, but could be confusing if the error was persistent and required debugging.
Improve the error handling overall to catch more error cases explicitly and respond better to edge cases.
Also update the terminology in comments to align with the RFC. Variable and function names were not changed because a refactor is intended for HTTP response and it doesn't seem worth the additional code churn.
The prior harness required a separate function to contain the server behavior but this made keeping the client/server code in sync very difficult and in general meant test writing took longer.
Now, commands to define server behavior are inline with the client code, which should greatly simplify test writing.
Bug Fixes:
* Fix issue checking if file links are contained in path links. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang. Reported by Christophe Cavallié.)
* Allow pg-path1 to be optional for synchronous archive-push. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang. Reported by Jerome Peng.)
* The expire command now checks if a stop file is present. (Fixed by Cynthia Shang. Reviewed by David Steele.)
* Handle missing reason phrase in HTTP response. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang. Reported by Tenuun.)
* Increase buffer size for lz4 compression flush. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang. Reported by Eric Radman.)
* Ignore pg-host* and repo-host* options for the remote command. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang. Reported by Pavel Suderevsky.)
* Fix possibly missing pg1-* options for the remote command. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang. Reported by Andrew L'Ecuyer.)
Features:
* Time-based retention for full backups. The --repo-retention-full-type option allows retention of full backups based on a time period, specified in days. (Contributed by Cynthia Shang, Pierre Ducroquet. Reviewed by David Steele.)
* Ad hoc backup expiration. Allow the user to remove a specified backup regardless of retention settings. (Contributed by Cynthia Shang. Reviewed by David Steele.)
* Zstandard compression support. Note that setting compress-type=zst will make new backups and archive incompatible (unrestorable) with prior versions of pgBackRest. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang.)
* bzip2 compression support. Note that setting compress-type=bz2 will make new backups and archive incompatible (unrestorable) with prior versions of pgBackRest. (Contributed by Stephen Frost. Reviewed by David Steele, Cynthia Shang.)
* Add backup/expire running status to the info command. (Contributed by Stefan Fercot. Reviewed by David Steele.)
Improvements:
* Expire WAL archive only when repo-retention-archive threshold is met. WAL prior to the first full backup was previously expired after the first full backup. Now it is preserved according to retention settings. (Contributed by Cynthia Shang. Reviewed by David Steele.)
* Add local MD5 implementation so S3 works when FIPS is enabled. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang, Stephen Frost. Suggested by Brian Almeida, John Kelley.)
* PostgreSQL 13 beta1 support. Changes to the control/catalog/WAL versions in subsequent betas may break compatibility but pgBackRest will be updated with each release to keep pace. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang.)
* Reduce buffer-size default to 1MiB. (Reviewed by Stephen Frost.)
* Throw user-friendly error if expire is not run on repository host. (Contributed by Cynthia Shang. Reviewed by David Steele.)
The purpose of the remote command is to get access to local resources, so a remote should never start another remote. However, this could happen if there were host settings on the remote host, which ended badly with lock errors, loops, etc.
Add pg-local and repo-local options to indicate that the resource is local even if there are host settings.
Note that for the time being these options are internal and not intended for general usage. However, this is likely the direction needed to allow for more symmetric and manageable configurations.
Some pg1-* options are required by the remote so if they are not provided in the remote's configuration file then it may cause a configuration error, depending on the operation. This currently only applies to the pg1-path option.
This is still an issue for repo-* options but the same solution cannot be applied because some repo-* options are secure and cannot be passed on the command-line.
There don't appear to be any behavioral changes since PostgreSQL 12 and all the tests pass.
Changes to the control/catalog/WAL versions in subsequent betas may break compatibility but pgBackRest will be updated with each release to keep pace.
S3 requires the Content-MD5 header for many requests but MD5 is not available via OpenSSL when FIPS is enabled because it is considered to be insecure.
Even though our usage does not present any security risks a local M5 implementation is required to circumvent the over-broad FIPS restriction.
Vendorize the MD5 implementation found at https://openwall.info/wiki/people/solar/software/public-domain-source-code/md5 and add full coverage for the module in the common/crypto unit tests.
The prior default was determined by benchmarking the Perl code prior to the 1.0 release. In general buffer allocation was more expensive in Perl so large buffers gave the best performance. This was due to multiple buffer allocations for each filter in an IO operation.
The C code allocates fixed buffers for each IO operation so the cost for buffer allocation is lower than Perl. That being the case it made sense to benchmark the C code to determine the optimal buffer default.
The performance/storage tests were used to measure the performance of a variety of filters. 1GiB of data was processed by each filter 10 times and the results of the tests were averaged.
While most buffer sizes gave similar performance, 1MiB appeared to perform the best overall. Of course, different architectures are likely to yield different results but this seems like a sensible default. The buffer-size option may still need to be manually configured to give optimal results.
Raw test data for reference:
4MB buffer (prior default)
copy time 1807ms, avg time 180ms, avg throughput: 5942MB/s
md5 time 14200ms, avg time 1420ms, avg throughput: 756MB/s
sha1 time 11431ms, avg time 1143ms, avg throughput: 939MB/s
sha256 time 23463ms, avg time 2346ms, avg throughput: 457MB/s
gzip -6 time 381199ms, avg time 38119ms, avg throughput: 28MB/s
lz4 -1 time 15484ms, avg time 1548ms, avg throughput: 693MB/s
1MB buffer (new default)
copy time 1760ms, avg time 176ms, avg throughput: 6100MB/s
md5 time 13739ms, avg time 1373ms, avg throughput: 781MB/s
sha1 time 11025ms, avg time 1102ms, avg throughput: 973MB/s
sha256 time 22539ms, avg time 2253ms, avg throughput: 476MB/s
gzip -6 time 372995ms, avg time 37299ms, avg throughput: 28MB/s
lz4 -1 time 15118ms, avg time 1511ms, avg throughput: 710MB/s
512K buffer
copy time 1782ms, avg time 178ms, avg throughput: 6025MB/s
md5 time 13724ms, avg time 1372ms, avg throughput: 782MB/s
sha1 time 10959ms, avg time 1095ms, avg throughput: 979MB/s
sha256 time 22982ms, avg time 2298ms, avg throughput: 467MB/s
gzip -6 time 378120ms, avg time 37812ms, avg throughput: 28MB/s
lz4 -1 time 15484ms, avg time 1548ms, avg throughput: 693MB/s
256K buffer
copy time 1805ms, avg time 180ms, avg throughput: 5948MB/s
md5 time 13706ms, avg time 1370ms, avg throughput: 783MB/s
sha1 time 11074ms, avg time 1107ms, avg throughput: 969MB/s
sha256 time 22588ms, avg time 2258ms, avg throughput: 475MB/s
gzip -6 time 372645ms, avg time 37264ms, avg throughput: 28MB/s
lz4 -1 time 16346ms, avg time 1634ms, avg throughput: 656MB/s
Improve the accuracy of the calculations in several areas with better integer expressions.
Make the input buffer size configurable. Previously it was always 1mb, i.e. block size.
Use a macro for output results to reduce code duplication.
Reason phrases (e.g. OK) are optional in HTTP 1.1 but the space after the status code is not. When the reason phrase was missing the required space was trimmed along with the trailing CR leading to a format error.
Rework the logic to preserve the space and allow empty reason phrases.
Found while testing against the Backblaze S3-compatible API.
