If the entire batch failed it would be retried, but individual file errors were not retried. This could cause pgBackRest to terminate during expiration or when removing an unresumable backup.
Rather than retry the entire batch, delete the errored files individually to take advantage of the HTTP retry rather than adding a new retry loop. These errors seem rare enough that it should not be a performance issue.
In theory, the additional stat() call after a file has been copied to the repo can determine if additional compression has been applied by the file system. However, it has been a very long time since we tested this in practice. There are currently no unit tests that accurately test this feature since it requires a compressed file system like ZFS to work, which never seemed worth the extra cost.
It can also add a lot of time to backups if there are a large quantity of small files.
In addition, it stands as a blocker for combining files for small file support since it is no longer possible to get per-file sizes from the viewpoint of the file system. There are several ways this could be reworked but none of them are easy while at the same time maintaining current info functionality.
It doesn't seem worth keeping an untested feature that will only work in some special cases (if it still works) when it is blocking development.
The most recent release of Minio has broken CI builds but there is no logging to indicate what is wrong.
For now, just use the prior release to get CI builds working again. This kind if breakage is not uncommon for Minio but they usually resolve it in the next release.
Update lock code to use standard common/io functions and module patterns. This module was developed before the common/io module existed and our patterns had stabilized.
The /etc/profile.d/lang.sh script was causing issues but it does not exist on amd64, so it seems the easiest thing was to remove it.
Fix how 32-bit VMs are determined now that another 64-bit architecture has been added.
And remove some obsolete VM hashes.
Previously manifest load required two passes through the file list, one to load the data and one to set the defaults. This required each file to be packed twice.
Instead simply note that the file value is default and then set the file defaults when they are loaded from the manifest. This is made possible by the different internal/external representations for files so the same method cannot be applied to paths and links.
This change seems to resolve the performance issues noted in 61ce586 but there is no obvious reason why.
Manifests with a very large number of files can use a considerable amount of memory. There are a lot of zeroes in the data so it can be stored more efficiently by using base-128 varint encoding for the integers and storing the strings in the same allocation.
The downside is that the data needs to be unpacked in order to be used, but in most cases this seems fast enough (about 10% slower than before) except for saving the manifest, which is 10% slower up to 10 million files and then gets about 5x slower by 100 million (two minutes on my M1 Mac). Profiling does not show this slowdown so I wonder if this is related to the change in memory layout. Curiously, the function that increased most was jsonFromStrInternal(), which was not modified. That gives more weight to the idea that there is some kind of memory issue going on here and one hopes that servers would be less affected. Either way, they largest use cases we have seen are for about 6 million files so if we can improve that case I believe we will be better off.
Further analysis showed that most of the time was taken up writing the size and timestamp fields, which makes almost no sense. The same amount of time was used if they were hard-coded to 0, which points to some odd memory issue on the M1 architecture.
This change has been planned for a while, but the particular impetus at this time is that small file support requires additional fields that would increase manifest memory usage by about 20%, even if the feature is not used.
Note that the Pack code has been updated to use the new varint encoder, but the decoder remains separate because it needs to fetch one byte at a time.
Manifest defaults for user, group, and mode were previously generated by scanning the data to find the most common values. This was very accurate but slow and complicated. It could also lead to surprising changes in the manifest when a default value suddenly changed.
Instead, use the $PGDATA path to generate defaults. In the vast majority of cases the same user/group should own all the path/files and the default file mode is easily derived from the path mode. There may be some edge cases where this generates larger manifests, but in general it reduces time and complexity when saving the manifest.
Remove the MCV code since it is longer longer used.
Change the mode back to 0700 earlier to reduce churn in the expect logs.
This will be especially important in a future commit that gets the defaults exclusively from the base path.
This flag was only being used by the backup command after manifestNewBuild() and had no other uses. There was a time when it was important for integration testing but the unit tests now fulfill this role.
Since backup is the only code concerned with the primary flag, move the code into the backup module.
We don't have any cross-version testing but this change was tested manually with the most recent version of pgBackRest to make sure it was tolerant of the missing primary info. When an older version of pgBackRest loads a newer manifest the primary flag will always be set to false, which is fine since it is not used.
Updating the manifest this way was not a great idea because it broke abstraction for the object. This meant certain changes to the interface and internals were not possible because the code was modifying internal manifest data.
Instead track the user replacements entirely in the restore module.
This also has the benefit of eliminating a pass over the manifest path/file/link lists.
AWS S3 integrates with AWS Key Management Service (AWS KMS) to provide server side encryption of S3 objects. This integration protects objects under encryption keys that never leave AWS KMS unencrypted.
The range feature allows reading out an arbitrary chunk of a file and will be important for efficient small file support.
Now that all drivers are required to support ranges remove the storageFeatureLimitRead feature flag that was implemented only by the Posix driver.
Do the replacement anywhere cfgOptionGroupIdxToKey() is being used to construct a group name in a message. cfgOptionGroupName() is better for this case since it also includes the name of the group so that it does not need to be repeated in each message.
Functionality to copy from IoRead to IoWrite is frequently used so centralize it. This also simplifies coverage testing in places where a loop was required before.
The backup LSNs are useful for performing LSN-based PITR. LSNs will not be displayed in the general text output (without --set) because they are probably not useful enough to deserve their own line.
There is no evidence that users need 8.3/8.4 anymore but it does cost us in terms of development and testing, especially now that we have a number of new backup/restore features planned.
It seems to make sense to remove this support now. If there are users who need to use/migrate from these versions they can use an older version of pgBackRest.
Bug Fixes:
* Fix restore delta link mapping when path/file already exists. (Reviewed by Reid Thompson. Reported by Younes Alhroub.)
* Fix socket leak on connection retries. (Reviewed by Reid Thompson. Reported by James Coleman.)
Features:
* Add TLS server. (Reviewed by Stephen Frost, Reid Thompson, Andrew L'Ecuyer.)
* Add --cmd option. (Contributed by Reid Thompson. Reviewed by Stefan Fercot, David Steele. Suggested by Virgile CREVON.)
Improvements:
* Check archive immediately after backup start. (Reviewed by Reid Thompson, David Christensen.)
* Add timeline and checkpoint checks to backup. (Reviewed by Stefan Fercot, Reid Thompson.)
* Check that clusters are alive and correctly configured during a backup. (Reviewed by Stefan Fercot.)
* Error when restore is unable to find a backup to match the time target. (Reviewed by Reid Thompson, Douglas J Hunley. Suggested by Douglas J Hunley.)
* Parse protocol/port in S3/Azure endpoints. (Contributed by Reid Thompson. Reviewed by David Steele.)
* Add warning when checkpoint_timeout exceeds db-timeout. (Contributed by Stefan Fercot. Reviewed by David Steele.)
* Add verb to HTTP error output. (Contributed by Christoph Berg. Reviewed by David Steele.)
* Allow y/n arguments for boolean command-line options. (Contributed by Reid Thompson. Reviewed by David Steele.)
* Make backup size logging exactly match info command output. (Contributed by Reid Thompson. Reviewed by David Steele. Suggested by Mahomed Hussein.)
Documentation Improvements:
* Display size option default and allowed values with appropriate units. (Reviewed by Reid Thompson.)
* Fix typos and improve documentation for the tablespace-map-all option. (Reviewed by Reid Thompson. Suggested by Reid Thompson.)
* Remove obsolete statement about future multi-repository support. (Suggested by David Christensen.)
Utilize httpUrlNewParseP() to parse endpoint and port from the URL in the S3 and Azure helpers to avoid issues where protocol was not expected to be part of the URL.
This leak was caused by the file descriptor variable getting clobbered after a long jump. Mark it as volatile to fix.
Testing this is a bit complex because the issue only happens in optimized builds, if at all. Put the test into the performance suite, which is always optimized, until a better idea presents itself.
If a path/file was remapped to a link using either --link-map or --link-all there would be no affect if the path/file already existed. If a link existed it would be properly updated and converting a link to a path/file also worked.
The issue happened during delta cleanup, which failed to check if the existing path/file had been remapped to a link.
Add checks for newly mapped path/file links and remove the old path/file we required.
This was previously a warning but the warning is easy to miss so a lot of time may be lost restoring and recovering a backup that will not hit the target.
Since this is technically a breaking change, add an "important note" about the change to the release.
In the backup command, add a warning if start-fast is disabled and the PostgreSQL checkpoint_timeout is greater than db-timeout.
In such cases, we might timeout before the checkpoint occurs and the backup really starts.
Fail the backup if a cluster stops or the standby is promoted. Previously, shutting down the primary would cause an error but it was not detected until the end of the backup. Now the error will happen sooner and a promotion on the standby will also cause an error.
SIGHUP allows the configuration to be reloaded. Note that the configuration will not be updated in child processes that have already started.
SIGTERM terminates the server process gracefully and sends SIGTERM to all child processes. This also gives the tests an easy way to stop the server.
Add the following checks:
* Checkpoint is updated in pg_control after pg_start_backup(). This helps ensure that PostgreSQL and pgBackRest have a consistent view of the storage and that PGDATA paths match.
* Timeline of backup start WAL file matches pg_control. Hard to see how this one could get hit, but we have the power...
* Standby is on the same timeline as the primary. If not, this standby is not following the primary.
* Last standby checkpoint is not greater than the backup checkpoint. If so, this standby is not following the primary.
This also requires some additional plumbing to read/write timeline/checkpoint from pg_control and parse timelines from WAL filenames. There were some changes in the backup tests caused by the fact that pg_control now has different contents for each backup.
The check to ensure that the required checkpoint was reached on the standby should also be updated to use pg_control (it currently uses pg_control_checkpoint()), but that requires non-trivial changes to the test harness and will need to wait.
A CHECK() worked exactly like ASSERT() except that it was compiled into production code. However, over time many checks have been added that should not throw AssertError, which should be reserved for probable coding errors.
Allow the error code to be specified so other error types can be thrown. Also add a human-readable message since many of these could be seen by users even when there is no coding error.
Update coverage exceptions for CHECK() to match ASSERT() since all conditions will never be covered.
These macros simplify management of pg_control test files.
Centralize time updates for pg_control in the command/backup module. This caused some time updates in the logs.
Finally, move the postgres module after the storage module so it can use storage macros.
hrnPgControlToBuffer() and hrnPgWalToBuffer() now generate the system id based on the version of Postgres. If a value less than 100 is specified for systemId then it will be added to the default system id so there can be multiple ids for a single version of PostgreSQL.
Add constants to represent version system ids in tests. These will eventually be auto-generated.
This changes some checksums and we no longer have big-endian tests systems, so X those checksums out so it is obvious they are no longer valid.
Tests that run without DEBUG for performance did not have ASSERT() and were using CHECK() instead.
Instead ensure that the ASSERT() macro is always available in tests.
Eliminate summing and passing of copied files sizes for logging backup size.
Instead, utilize infoBackupDataByLabel() to pull the backup size for the log message.
This allows boolean boolean command-line options to work like their config file equivalents.
At least for now this behavior will remain undocumented since all examples in the documentation will continue to use the standard syntax. The idea is that it will "just work" when options are copied out of config files rather than generating an error.
Previously the archive was only checked at the end of the backup to ensure all WAL required to make the backup consistent was present. The problem was that if archiving was not functioning then the backup had to complete before the user found out, which could be a while if the database was large enough.
Add an archive check immediately after backup start so failures are reported earlier.
The trick is to determine which WAL to check. If the repo is new there may not be any WAL in it and pg_start_backup() will not switch the WAL segment if it is empty. These are both likely scenarios when setting up and/or testing pgBackRest.
If the WAL segment is switched by pg_start_backup(), then check the archive for the segment that was detected prior to backup start. This should be common on normal running clusters with regular activity. Note that this might not be the segment immediately prior to the backup start segment if WAL volume is high.
If pg_start_backup() did not switch the WAL then we can force a switch on PostgreSQL >= 9.3 by creating a restore point. In that case the WAL to check will be the backup start WAL. This is most likely to happen on idle systems, during testing, or immediately after a repo switch.
An advantage of this approach other than earlier notification is that the backup directory will not be created so no resume will be attempted on the next backup.
Note that some additional churn was created in backup.c because the load of archive.info needs to be done earlier.
This is easier to read than using infoBackupDataByLabel() != NULL.
It also allows an assertion to be added to infoBackupDataByLabel() to ensure that a NULL return value is not used unsafely.
This test was lost due to a syntax issue in a58635ac.
Update the test to use system() to better mimic what postgres does and add logging so pgBackRest timing can be determined.
Properly log the size of files copied during the backup, matching the backup size returned from the info command.
In the reference issue, the incremental backup after switchover logs the size of all files evaluated rather than only the size of the files copied in the backup.
This appears to have been an attempt to not delete files that we don't recognize, but it only works in narrow cases and could leave the user is a position of not being able to complete the stanza delete without manual intervention. It seems better just to proceed with the delete, especially since the info files have already been removed.
In addition, deleting the manifests individually could be slow on object stores if there were a very large number of backups.
Size option default and allowed values were displayed in bytes, which was confusing for the user.
This also lays the groundwork for adding units to time options.
Move option parsing functions into a common module so they can be used from the build module.
Allows users to provide an executable to be used when pgbackrest generates command strings that expect to invoke pgbackrest. These generated commands are written to files by pgbackrest, e.g. recovery.conf.
The error handler used a loop to process try, catch, and finally blocks. This worked fine but static analysis tools like Coverity did not understand that the finally block would always run and so there were false positives about double-free, unfreed resource, etc.
This implementation removes the loop, which simplifies everything, and makes it clear that the finally block will always run. This cuts down on Coverity false positives.
This implementation also catches lack of coverage on empty catch blocks so a few test fixes were committed separately in d74fe7a.
A small refactor in backup.c is required because gcc 10.3.1 on Fedora 33 complains that the reason variable may be used uninitialized. It's not clear why this is the case, but reducing the scope of the TRY block fixes the issue.
Rather the converting String to StringIds at runtime, store defaults in StringId format in parse.auto.c and convert user input to StringId during parsing.
The compress-type, repo-type and log-level-* options have allow lists, which means it is more efficient to treat them as StringIds.
For compress-type and log-level-* also update the functions that convert them to enums.
The strIdFrom*() forced the caller to pick an encoding, which led to a number of TRY...CATCH blocks in the code. In practice the caller does not care which encoding is used as long as the string is valid for some encoding.
Update the strIdFrom*() function to try all possible encodings and only throw an error when the string is not valid for any of them.
Bug Fixes:
* Allow "global" as a stanza prefix. (Reviewed by Stefan Fercot. Reported by Younes Alhroub.)
* Fix segfault on invalid GCS key file. (Reviewed by Stephen Frost. Reported by Henrik Feldt.)
Improvements:
* Allow link-map option to create new links. (Reviewed by Don Seiler, Stefan Fercot, Chris Bandy. Suggested by Don Seiler.)
* Increase max index allowed for pg/repo options to 256. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang.)
* Add WebIdentity authentication for AWS S3. (Reviewed by James Callahan, Reid Thompson, Benjamin Blattberg, Andrew L'Ecuyer.)
* Report backup file validation errors in backup.info. (Contributed by Stefan Fercot. Reviewed by David Steele.)
* Add recovery start time to online backup restore log. (Reviewed by Tom Swartz, Stefan Fercot. Suggested by Tom Swartz.)
* Report original error and retries on local job failure. (Reviewed by Stefan Fercot.)
* Rename page checksum error to error list in info text output. (Reviewed by Stefan Fercot.)
* Add hints to standby replay timeout message. (Reviewed by Cynthia Shang, Stefan Fercot. Suggested by Leigh Downs.)
Since CentOS 8 will be EOL at the end of the year it makes sense to do this now. The centos:8 image is still used in documentation.xml because changes there require manual testing, which will need to be done at a later date. The changes are not user-facing, however, and can be done at any time.
Also update CentOS references to RHEL since that is what we are emulating for testing purposes.
Currently empty CATCH() blocks are always marked as covered because of the loop structure of error handling.
A prototype implementation of error handling without looping has shown that these CATCH() blocks are not covered without new tests. Whether or not that prototype gets committed it is worth adding the tests.
This is mostly to revert some comment changes in b11ab9f7 that will break the ppc64le patch, but at the same time keep the spelling consistent in all comments and documentation.
Also revert some space changes for the same reason.
Azurite released another breaking change (see fbd018cd, 096829b3, c38d6926, and Azurite issue 1039) so make adjustments as needed to documentation and tests.
Also remove some dead code that hid the repo-storage-host option and was made obsolete by all these changes.
The variants were needed to easily serialize configurations for the Perl code.
Unions are more efficient and will allow us to add new types that are not supported by variants, e.g. StringId.
These flags are used for all tests but it was not possible to add them to configure before the change in 046d6643. This is especially important for adhoc tests to ensure the flags are not forgotten.
Remove the flags from test make commands where they were being applied.
There is no change for production builds.
The TLS server is an alternative to using SSH for protocol connections to remote hosts.
This command is currently experimental and intended only for trial and testing. As such, the new commands and options will not show up in the command-line help unless directly requested.
Some tests can generate very large error messages for diffs and they often get cut off before the end.
Also fix a test so it does not create too large a buffer on the stack.
The previous format was custom for configuration parsing and was not as expressive as the pack format. An immediate benefit is that commands with the same optional rules are merged.
Defaults are now represented correctly (not multiplied), which simplifies the option default functions used by help.
These allow packs to be created without allocating a buffer in the case that the buffer already exists or the data is in a global constant.
Also fix a rendering issue in hrnPackReadToStr().
The vast majority of Strings are never modified so for most cases allocate memory for the string with the object. This results in one allocation in most cases instead of two. Use strNew() if strCat*() functions are needed.
Update varNewStr() in the same way since String Variants can never be modified. This results in one allocation in all cases instead of three. Also update varNewStrZ() to use STR() instead of strNewZ() to save two more allocations.
A stanza name like global_stanza was not allowed because the code was not selective enough about how a global section should be formatted.
Update the config parser to correctly recognize global sections.
Remove the hardcoded storage helpers from storageRepoGet() except for the the built-in Posix helper and the special remote helper.
The goal is to make storage driver development a bit easier by isolating as much of the code as possible into the driver module. This also makes coverage reporting much simpler for additional drivers since they do not need to provide coverage for storage/helper.
Consolidate the CIFS tests into the Posix tests since CIFS is just a special case of the Posix.
Test all storage features in the Posix test so that other storage driver tests do not need to provide coverage for storage/storage.
Remove some dead code in the storage/s3 test.
Currently link-map only allows links that exist in the backup manifest to be remapped to a new destination.
Allow link-map to create a new link as long as a valid path/file from the backup is referenced.
The local process will retry jobs (e.g. backup file) but after a certain number of failures gives up. Previously, the last error was reported but generally the first error is far more valuable. The last error is likely to be a cascade failure such as the protocol being out of sync.
Report the first error (and stack trace) and append the retry errors to the first error without stack trace information.
Currently errors found during the backup are only available in text output when specifying --set.
Add a flag to backup.info that is available in both the text and json output when --set is not specified. This at least provides the basic info that an error was found in the cluster during the backup, though details are still only available as described above.
These tests run in a container without permissions to mount tempfs, so add an option to ci.pl to not create tempfs. Also add some packages not in the base image.
